Plication shortens the longer side of the penis to straighten it and suits moderate curves in men with good erections. Plaque incision with grafting lengthens the shorter side and suits severe or complex deformity, but only when erections are strong. When rigidity has already failed, an implant with straightening treats both problems at once.
The short version
- Curves under about 60°, without hourglass narrowing, in a man with good erections and adequate length are usually treated with plication.
- Curves over about 60°, hourglass narrowing or a hinge that buckles usually need plaque incision with grafting — but only if erections are strong without any treatment.
- Plication costs roughly 1–2 cm of length and carries a low risk to erections. Grafting preserves length but worsens erections in roughly 10–25% of men.
- If rigidity is already poor, the answer is usually neither: an inflatable implant with straightening in the same operation.
- A residual curve of up to 20° is accepted, because chasing a perfectly straight shaft adds risk without adding function.
- We form a provisional plan from your online case review and confirm the final choice at the in-person assessment in Istanbul.
Two ways to straighten the same bend
In Peyronie’s disease a plaque of inelastic scar in the tunica albuginea stops one side of the penis stretching during erection, so the shaft bends towards it. There are only two ways to make that shaft straight again. You can shorten the long, healthy side until it matches the short side — that is plication. Or you can release the short side by cutting the plaque and patching the gap so it matches the long side — that is plaque incision with grafting.
Both straighten more than 90% of men to within 20°. The difference is what each costs you, which is why the decision rests on four measurements rather than surgeon preference. Everything below assumes the disease is stable — no change in the curve for three months and pain resolved. If you are not sure that applies to you, read whether your Peyronie’s is stable enough for surgery first.
Two related questions have their own articles: will Peyronie’s surgery shorten my penis, and sensation and orgasm after grafting surgery.
The four things that decide the operation
Each is recorded at the <a href="/treatments/peyronies-disease/#assessment">curvature assessment</a>, during an erection induced in clinic, because home photographs of a partial erection tend to underestimate the bend.
- Degree of curvature. Measured in degrees with a goniometer at full rigidity. As a working rule, curves under about 60° are suited to plication and curves over about 60° — or curves in two planes at once — lean towards grafting.
- Shape of the shaft. An hourglass narrowing, an indentation, or a hinge where the shaft buckles under pressure means the plaque is weakening the erection itself. Plication cannot fix a waist or a hinge; grafting can, because it rebuilds the narrowed segment.
- Erectile rigidity and Doppler findings. We note how firm your erections are without any treatment, and duplex Doppler shows arterial inflow and whether there is venous leak. Grafting needs genuinely strong erections to begin with. Poor rigidity or significant venous leak points towards an implant instead.
- Stretched penile length. Documented before any decision. A man who is already short with a large curve has little length to spare, which shifts the choice from plication towards grafting, or towards an implant.
Decision table: which findings point where
This is how the measurements usually combine. Many real cases sit between the rows.
| Your findings | Usually points to | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Curve under about 60°, no hourglass, good erections, adequate length | Plication | Straightens reliably with the lowest risk to erections; the 1–2 cm cost is affordable. |
| Curve over about 60°, good erections without treatment | Grafting | Plication would cost too much length at this angle; grafting keeps it. |
| Hourglass narrowing or hinge instability, good erections | Grafting | Only rebuilding the narrowed segment restores a stable, uniform shaft. |
| Moderate curve but short stretched length | Grafting, or implant if rigidity is borderline | Further shortening would be poorly tolerated. |
| Any curve with poor rigidity or venous leak on Doppler | Implant with straightening | A straight penis that cannot become rigid is still unusable; grafting would also worsen erections further. |
The angles are working guides, not hard cut-offs. A 55° curve with an hourglass may need grafting; a 65° curve in a long penis may still suit plication.
What each operation costs you
Neither operation is free of trade-offs. The question is which set fits your anatomy and your erections.
| Plication | Plaque incision with grafting | |
|---|---|---|
| Length | Shortens by roughly 1–2 cm, more with larger curves | Preserved; some men recover a little of what the plaque took |
| Erections | Low risk of worsening; the erectile tissue is not opened | Roughly 10–25% notice weaker erections afterwards |
| Feel | Sutures or knots may be palpable under the skin, especially in slim men; they soften over months | No knots; the repaired area may feel slightly different |
| Operative time | Usually around 60–90 minutes | Usually around 90–150 minutes |
| After surgery | No stretching protocol; intercourse at 6–8 weeks after review | Stretching or vacuum protocol from about week 4; intercourse at 6–8 weeks |
The graft is processed pericardial material, sized to the defect at the operating table. Over the following months the body grows its own tissue into it, so it becomes part of the erectile wall. A graft left to heal in a shortened position can contract, which is why the stretching programme matters.
The third option: implant with straightening
Many men with Peyronie’s disease also have erectile dysfunction, sometimes because the same plaque damages the veno-occlusive mechanism. If erections are no longer firm enough without treatment, or no longer respond to treatment at all, straightening alone leaves a straight penis that still cannot be used. Grafting would add its own risk of weakening erections further.
The answer is usually an inflatable implant with straightening in one operation. The cylinders are placed inside the erectile bodies and the shaft is straightened over them — usually by manual modelling, with a plaque incision or graft if the curve persists. It is irreversible, as any implant is, and we discuss that plainly. More on the device itself is on our penile implant page.
How the decision is made in practice
- Online case review You send history, photographs of the erect penis from above and the side, and any previous scans. Prof. Kadıoğlu’s team gives a provisional recommendation and tells you which findings could change it.
- Assessment in Istanbul Induced erection, goniometer measurement, duplex Doppler and stretched length on the first day. The final choice of operation is confirmed here, face to face, and explained before you consent.
- Surgery and hospital night One night in hospital. Plication or grafting under general or spinal anaesthetic, as agreed.
- Days 5–7 Wound review and instructions for your specific protocol, then you fly home.
- Weeks 4–8 Stretching or vacuum protocol from about week 4 after grafting; intercourse at 6–8 weeks after review, by video if you prefer.
Next step
The Peyronie’s correction package covers the assessment, whichever operation is chosen, graft material where needed, the hospital night and twelve months of follow-up; it is quoted after your assessment findings are reviewed, and how pricing is structured is explained in Peyronie’s surgery cost. For an overview of the condition, start at our Peyronie’s disease hub. When you are ready, send your details through our case review form and we will tell you which operation your findings currently point to.
Questions we are asked
Is grafting a more advanced operation than plication?
It is more complex, not more advanced in the sense of being preferable. For a moderate curve in a man with good erections, plication straightens just as reliably with less risk to erections. Grafting earns its extra risk only when the curve, an hourglass or the length you have makes plication unsuitable.
My curve is around 60°. Which operation will I have?
At that angle the shape of the shaft, your rigidity and your stretched length usually decide it. An hourglass or a short penis tips the choice towards grafting; a long penis with a simple curve and strong erections may still suit plication. We confirm it at the in-person assessment.
Will I be able to feel the stitches after plication?
Some men can feel small knots under the skin, especially if they are slim. We bury the knots where possible; they soften over months and are rarely noticed during intercourse.
Why not graft everyone to avoid losing length?
Because grafting carries a roughly 10–25% risk of weaker erections, compared with a low risk after plication. For many men, trading 1–2 cm for that safety margin is the sensible choice. Length matters, but so does a reliable erection.
What if my erections are already weakening?
Then grafting is usually not appropriate, and plication may leave you with a straight penis that still does not work reliably. An inflatable implant with straightening treats both problems in one operation. Doppler at your assessment helps make that call.
Can the decision change once I arrive in Istanbul?
Yes, occasionally. Photographs give a good provisional plan, but the measured angle under full rigidity and the Doppler findings sometimes differ from what was expected. If they change the recommendation, we explain why before anything is scheduled.
Written by Prof. Dr. Ateş Kadıoğlu, MD, FECSM, professor of urology, and medically reviewed by Prof. Dr. Ateş Kadıoğlu, MD, FECSM, last reviewed . This article describes typical findings reported in the surgical literature and in our own practice; individual cases vary and nothing here is a substitute for a personal consultation. See our medical disclaimer.